You are not logged in. Access is limited. Login or see membership information. • Natural Jewish Parenting

The NJP Blogs

In this section, we present an ever-growing collection of brief articles, essays, poetry, news, recipes, and more—all contributed by our members.

These blogs represent each individual writer's viewpoint. Please keep that in mind as you read and comment. Feel free to disagree, but be respectful of differences.

Note to members: You can start your own blog here, in the "Window Into My World" section. (Please don't start new blogs in any of the other categories.) Instead of or in addition to your own blog, you can also contribute to almost all of the blogs listed below as a guest blogger.

Before starting your own blog, or if you're interested in being a guest blogger in one or more of the categories listed below, please contact Yael for guidelines. It's easy to get started. This section needs YOU!


Watch this Blog Notify me by e-mail any time a new post is made to this blog.

Yael Resnick
Group Co-Administrator

"Yael"

by Yael Resnick, editor of Natural Jewish Parenting

July 2010 Posts

Archives

Personal Thoughts on Parenting
Blog Entry

Still learning after all these years

Wednesday, July 14th 2010 @ 1:32 AM

Just when you think you’ve got the hang of this bringing-up-baby thing, you realize you don’t. Or at least, that's what happened to me.

I thought I knew how “my babies” go. They talk very early and walk very late. While I fill pages and pages with their cute word mispronunciations (starting well before they hit their first birthdays), I wait with a bit of anxiety for them to attempt to take a step on their own.

Yep, that’s how it goes with my babies. Or so I thought, until my new baby, my fifth. You’d think by baby number five I wouldn’t have too much left to learn. But this super-cute little creature is almost 15 months old, and she does not say one recognizable word. Well, maybe one, but you have to be very creative to catch it. Most of the time, she babbles, or just says “uh uh uh" and points to things.

I coach her, "Say ma-ma-ma-ma-mommy!” She mouths it along with me, but doesn't verbalize it, and never initiates it on her own. She'll mimic inflections and all kinds of silly sounds, she has a great sense of humor, and she understands everything—but she seems determined not to speak a word. Is she really my baby? Well, of course—just a whole new person with a timetable of her own.

I try not to worry about her. I know that she will develop at her own pace, and she is moving (inching) along in the direction of speaking. But I’m used to having conversations with babies of this age, and with her, I’m still knee-deep in the guessing-game stage. It’s hard!

Honestly, I don’t expect her to be walking, though. “My babies” never walk at this age. But they do try to stand alone... although my new little one rarely does. She crawls, goes up stairs, and cruises just a bit, but standing seems far off. Meanwhile other toddlers her age are running around! You would think after five children, I wouldn’t compare. And the truth is, I never used to. So why is it different this time around? It’s hard to say.

She’s also a teeny-tiny thing. One of my other kids was also tiny at this age, but somehow I never worried. So why, if I’m such a seasoned, been-there-done-that mother, am I worried about this latest tiny thing? I look at her oh-so-dainty (don’t call them scrawny) arms and legs and her petite face and it’s hard not to say, “Grow already!!”

She “fell off” her growth curve. Her doctor is concerned and has done tests. I’m usually impervious to worry about this kind of thing; as a natural optimist, I tend to assume things will work themselves out just fine. But I took the doctor’s advice to supplement with vitamin D to correct a deficiency, and I’ve ramped up my ongoing efforts to get my baby to eat some actual food. I’ve been trying to get her to eat (or drink) since she was ten months old, but for all intents and purposes, she’s still exclusively nursing. Clearly, she needs more.

“My babies” always eat plenty of food by this age! But not this baby.

So I’m finding that after being a mother for 16 years, for the first time I am worrying, “Is my baby developing normally?” I didn’t worry when one of my kids didn’t walk until almost 20 months old. I didn’t worry when another was a super-skinny toddler. So why is it different now, with baby number five? Are the facts of her development any more worrisome, objectively speaking? I don't think so. She is most likely somewhere on the continuum of normal, just on the slower end of the curve. But on a gut level, I just feel different. Maybe in my ripe older age, I’m becoming more protective and more cautious, less willing to wait things out and hope for the best. Or maybe my instincts are alerting me to something not being quite right.

In any case, this is an all-new experience for me. And I’m learning (again, because I know I have learned this lesson many times in many different ways) that there really is no such thing as being an expert when it comes to parenting. Over many years of being parents, we can develop skills and emotional resources that we will use again and again, and that’s very helpful. But experience can also be a pitfall, when it leads to assumptions about what is normal and expected—if not for all children, then for “my children”—and those assumptions turn out to be wrong.

I would say that if there is a way to be a parenting expert, it would be to let go of expectations, and to simply be present and tuned in to each child (and ready to intervene when needed) at every step along the way.

Comments

shifra goldstein
Aishes Chayil
msg said on Wednesday, July 14th 2010 @ 4:57 AM:

BH

Very true, Yael. Let me just add that this is true all the way down the road, meaning that what you wrote is true even with the teenagers, the over 20s and even with the married ones!!! That's why the experience you gain when they are small is so vital to use for later. And by "experience" I mean YOUR OWN ATTITUDE AND TRUST IN HASHEM!! Like the Rebbetzin here says: the kids will be fine, they came her to educate US!!!

shifra

 

 


Liora Pearlman
Aishes Chayil
LioraPearlman said on Wednesday, July 14th 2010 @ 6:47 AM:

I've been studying late talking (I have a 17 month old with Down syndrome)  and I'm really excited by Dr. James MacDonald's revolutionary ideas.  (see his book Play To Talk, it's wonderful, and the group http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/communicating/)

sounds like your baby is communicating well!

He focuses on building preverbal skills like

vocal turn taking

matching

balancing

see more at the yahoo group (sign up) and here http://jamesdmacdonald.org  but honestly you'll get a lot more good stuff at the group (he's a frequent poster!) let me dig up a sample

 

uh oh it's copyrighted  hope this is okay.  This is more geared to kids with real delays, but I think that the principles can be the same for babies learnign to talk as well. Ten or Twenty minutes, getting in the baby's space, and interacting with him with Jim's principles. 

Just first, think of how *most* speech therapists talk.  "Hi, Jimmy How are You Today?  (silence) "Did you come in the car today?  Fun car ride, Huh? "  (silence)  "Are you ready to play our games?  [pause} "Which one do you want to start with?"  ok now contrast that with what he says below.  Especially elimintating questions.  Just making statements, and pausing for what seems a *very* long time.  It is not a magic instantaneous fix.  But it does help communication and balance can bring someone out of her shell.  Less is more!  Liora

[Ed. note: Articles have been edited out for copyright reasons and will be reposted after I get permission.]

another thing he wrote at the group recently is this:

One thin I'd add is for you to have once a week a family meeting for half an hour called "GET {child} TO TALK   make as many family members attend and give them this assignment, to be reported on weekly.
1. Ten minutes a day, play  in {child's} work doing just what he does with no criticism at all.
2.  Match what he does and sounds- in the play session but also in daily contacts-  be sure you act and communicate in ways he can do and succeed in.
3. Balance;  do only as much as he does then wait for more. Be sure to not do so much that it is impossible for him to try.
4.  Be playful;  be more interesting than his instructions.
5. Take turns- keep him in longer turn exchanges with any actions or sounds he can do.
Many families have found these guides  to get children to interact more so they can eventually communicate more.
And tell the family the  HELPLESSNESS RULE  The more you do things for him that he can do for himself, the  less he will develop.  And the more he interacts now the more he will communicate later.

Hope this helps, it has for us!  Liora


Liora Pearlman
Aishes Chayil
LioraPearlman said on Wednesday, July 14th 2010 @ 6:54 AM:

nutritionally I'd look into

1) evaluate for (or do diet elimination/challenge/rechallenge) looking for food allergies

2) hemoglobin (and ferritin) levels, and thyroid

3) give probiotics

4) supplementing with some fats.  Even 1/2 teaspoon of coconut oil a day can add a lot of calories.

5) Super foods.  Smoothies, milkshakes, add in greens if you can.  Avocado, blueberries, carob candy.

6) add in at nighttime to enhance growth factor (the GF hormone is manufactured during deep sleep) Add in Vitamin B6, L-Ornithine and L-Tryptophan.

Is it the texture of foods that bothers her, or the flavor, or does she just not seem hungry?  Does she enjoy dipping and playing with foods, and such?  (try grilled firm tofu in egg batter).   Lots of healthy snacks can become meals. Tofu Spice cookies (from the Heimishe Kitchen cookbook)  Pumpkin Granola Bars, carob candy, black bean brownies, etc. she can eat as much as she wants and they taste like treats.  If eggs are on your list to try eliminating, grind up 1 T of flax seeds, and steep in 2T of warm water till gelatinous for baking and recipes (sorry, probably won't be good for frying tofu though!). 

I don't suppose you vaccinate, but if you do, I would definitely delay vaccinating a kid who seems sort of fragile like this.  Especially live viruses.  Stay far away from the MMR and MMRV. 

Liora


Yael Resnick
Aishes Chayil
Yael said on Wednesday, July 14th 2010 @ 9:51 AM:

Quote from LioraPearlman on Wednesday, July 14th 2010 @ 6:47 AM

I've been studying late talking (I have a 17 month old with Down syndrome)  and I'm really excited by Dr. James MacDonald's revolutionary ideas.  (see his book Play To Talk, it's wonderful, and the group http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/communicating/)

<snip>

Hope this helps, it has for us!  Liora

Thank you for this, Liora! Some of this I do naturally - using one word (and repeating it) to tell my baby what she is doing or trying to communicate. Many of the ideas in this article are extremely useful to me.

I would like to get permission from the author to post these excerpts here. Then I will put them on their own page, linked to your comment. For now, I've edited them out for copyright reasons.


Gilla weiss
NJP Community
GillaWeiss said on Wednesday, July 14th 2010 @ 3:21 PM:

Yes, when we are young we tend to be confident and somewhat ignorant ( not meant negatively...quite the opposite:) When we get a bit older and wiser, we have seen more  and experienced more and our eyes are open and we can see things we didn't when we were younger. We have the experience and strength to allow ourselves a certain vulnerability,.......a "what if" moment and even voice it.

She sounds adorable and I would definitely look into ways of naturally boosting her. 

Liora gave you some great tips (thanks Liora for that link :)) Fats like vitamin A & D are cruciall to growing babies and children and fats are brainfood!! Fatty fish (fish oil) butter, are great sources for a growing body. I don't know if you are vegetarian or not, but it can be challenging sometimes when kids are not thriving and foods like bone broth is so nutritious and rich in minerals and can be used as a base for so many foods and adds flavor to everything too. 

coconut oil & milk or cream are great additions to the diet and make everything yummy, coconut oil is a medium chain fatty acid which makes it quite unique.

Many times correcting vitamin and especially mineral/fat deficiencies  can  be that missing link...and if it isn't, you go with your gut and try the next thing.

I was just smiling while reading, most of my kids were also very early talkers and and by the time they were Yosef's age ( my 19 month old baby) they were  talking up a storm!! Yosef has down syndrome and while he Baruch Hashem communicates well and even makes a few signs, says abba and more and " meee"  for nursing, he is not talking and here Iam learning new things, new tricks, reading, researching, asking.  

Btw, do you sign with her?  I never even thought of it for my other kids, but it has become a part of our life now and all the kids are learning ASL so, it's good for everyone :) 


Yael Resnick
Aishes Chayil
Yael said on Wednesday, July 14th 2010 @ 10:10 PM:

Shifra - Wise words!!

Liora - Your nutritional advice is excellent and will hopefully help me in the future (or help other people now), but right now my baby just does not eat. She will eat a few microspoonfuls of something soft if I feed it to her. She will suck on a solid food item (daintily holding it like a fascinating specimen between her thumb and forefinger), but only a tiny bit of mush actually goes in her mouth. If there is anything to chew, it comes back out. She doesn't chew. She will get a drop of two from a bottle (my first baby who I am actively trying to get to use a bottle!), but she doesn't actually drink.

She nurses fine, so I know she knows how to swallow, but she doesn't seem to want to apply that skill to anything else... although she does seem to enjoy making a dainty little mess of whatever is in front of her.

Oh, and no, she is not vaccinated. And she has had one cold in her life and aside from her size and slowish reaching of milestones, otherwise quite healthy.

Gilla - I am definitely hoping that addressing the vitamin D deficiency (with supplements and sunlight) will fill in one important missing link. She seems to enjoy ice cream (not sure how much gets eaten, though)... any ideas for how to get healthier fats and other nutrients into her by way of some kind of frozen treat?


Yael Resnick
Aishes Chayil
Yael said on Wednesday, July 21st 2010 @ 1:17 AM:

Quote from GillaWeiss on Wednesday, July 14th 2010 @ 3:21 PM

Btw, do you sign with her?  I never even thought of it for my other kids, but it has become a part of our life now and all the kids are learning ASL so, it's good for everyone :) 

I just realized I never responded to this part.

I signed with some of my other kids when they were babies (my oldest invented over one hundred signs of her own), but since they talked early it wasn't so necessary. I've been trying to teach my baby to sign, but I have to say she really hasn't taken to it.

I'm actually slightly fluent-ish in ASL because I studied it in college and was at one point planning to become an interpreter. So signing is something that comes naturally to me with babies... but this baby doesn't seem to want to do it! (She does, however, enjoy grabbing people's noses.)


Yael Resnick
Aishes Chayil
Yael said on Monday, August 2nd 2010 @ 2:21 AM:

First of all, thanks again to all who responded here and by e-mail with suggestions and support. It all helps!

Now, a quick update: 

We've scheduled appointments with a pediatric gastroenterologist and an early intervention person. Doing our due diligence to explore all possibilities. But really, the more I read, the more I think she's just a wee little thing who will blossom when she's ready.

She's standing on her own a bit, cruising faster and more confidently, babbling more purposefully and saying a few definite words (Mommy!). She's sleeping a little better and seems like a happy baby. So I'm trying not to worry!


© Natural Jewish Parenting. All rights reserved. Please do not reprint any content found on this site, in whole or in part, in electronic or print form, without permission from the publisher. • NJP is a project of Jewish Education Alternatives